Welcome to
Burns Country - Home
 
Search This Site
 

Everything you wanted to know about Robert Burns, Scotland's national bard (and lots more besides). Please let us know if anything's missing, wrong, or just plain wonderful

Burns Country Collage

AULD LANG SYNE
Words | Karaoke!

Burns Shop
Poems and Songs
Burns Encyclopaedia
Burns Suppers
Burns Cottage and Park
Burns in English
Burns Chess Set
Burns Links
Scotweb Mall
 
robert burns store
View our exclusive range of distinctive Robert Burns related products.

Register with our Shopping Club for further offers and unique member offers.

Contact us:
info@robertburns.org


The Burns Encyclopedia
Home | Introduction | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

Blair, the Reverend Dr Hugh

Dr Blair, of whom Dr Blacklock had written: 'His taste is too polished and his genius too regular in its emotions to make allowances of a more impetuous ardour', communicated his views to Burns on the proposed second edition of his poems. Blair's undated notes, published in the Burns Chronicle of 1932, throw clear light on the orthodoxy of his literary tastes:

["A Dedication to G- H- Esq.;", line 49] The Line And och — that's nae Regen-n — ought to be omitted as Mr Burns agreed.

[Ibid, ll. 68ff.] The Paragraph beginning with this line O ye what leave the spring o' C-lv-n — had much better I think be omitted. The Poem will be better without it, & it will give offence by the ludicrous views of the punishments of Hell.

["Epistle to J. R.-", stanzas 7ff.] The Description of shooting the hen is understood, I find, to convey an indecent meaning: tho' in reading the poem, I confess, I took it literally, and the indecency did not strike me. But if the Author meant to allude to an affair with a Woman, as its supposed, the whole Poem ought undoubtedly to be left out of the new edition.

["The Holy Fair", stanza 12] The line — wi'tidings of Sal-v-n — ought to be alter'd as it gives just offence. The Author may easily contrive some other Rhyme in place of the word Sal-v-n

["Address to the Deil", stanza 11] The stanza of — There be mystic knots make great abuse — had better be left out, as indecent.

["A Dream", stanza 13] The stanza — Young Royal Tarry Breeks, I learn — is also coarse, and had better be omitted.

["Epitaph for G.H. Esq.;"] The last line — May I be saved or d-d — is very exceptionable. The general thought may remain, may I be with him wherever he is — but may be d-d with him, is too much, & ought undoubtedly to be altered.

Of the proposed additions to the New Edition some are very good. The best, I think, are — "John Barleycorn" — "Death & Dr, Hornbook" — "The Winter Night" — the verses left in a friend's house where the Author slept.

There are a few which in my opinion ought not to be published.

The two stanzas to the tune of "Gilliecrankie", which refer to the death of Zimir and Cozbi as related in the book of Numbers, are beyond doubt quite inadmissible.

The Verses entitled "The Prophet" and "God's Complaint", from the 15th Ch. Of Jeremiah, are also inadmissible. They would be considered burlesquing the Scriptures.

The Whole of What is called the Cantata, the Song of the Beggars and their Doxies* with the Grace at the end of them, are altogether unfit in my opinion for publication. They are by much too licentious; and fall below the dignity which Mr Burns possesses in the rest of his poems & would rather degrade them.

These observations are Submitted by one who is a great friend to Mr Burn's Poems and wishes him to preserve the fame of Virtuous Sensibility, & of humorous fun, without offence.

*Refers to 'Love and Liberty' ('The Jolly Beggars')

Buy the Burns Encyclopedia online
Home | Introduction | A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

Robert Burns Store

NEW!! robert burns store View our exclusive range of distinctive Robert Burns related products. Register with our Shopping Club for further offers and unique member offers.Click here...


Complete Burns Songs

linn recordings of burns Linn Records have completed their landmark recording of all 368 Burns songs, available as individual CDs or a 12 volume presentation box set. We have full details. Click here...


Burns Music & Recordings
Search our huge CD and music store for any Burns-related phrase!
Hint: Type "lang syne" or "peck maut" etc. into the Search box there for all artists, titles, descriptions or track listings with the words entered.
Burns Chess Sets

Burns Chess SetsUnique collectors' pieces based on Burns' life and works. (The ideal gift for your Burns Supper guests!) Click here...

Scotweb Store

ScotwebThe finest Scottish shopping site in the world, with the world's largest choice of kilts and tartans, exclusive jewelry, Highland Dress, Bagpipes and piping supplies, cashmere, and much more. Buying from these sites helps pay for the upkeep of Burns Country! Click here...